HATO PIÑERO'S OWNERS SPEAK

HATO PIÑERO: A Model for Sustainable Development
As the Venezuelan government, through the National Land Institute (INTI), moves to expropriate Hato Piñero, the owners of this cattle ranch and world renowned nature preserve make the information herewith public with the aim of exposing the truth of the origin, ownership, productivity, administration and scientific, ecological research, and ecotourism operations of C. A. Agropecuaria San Francisco, Hato Piñero and Hato Paraima, serving as official response to the allegations and the baseless accusations made by INTI.

We ask you to visit this site often to obtain updates and more information.

ABOUT OUR SITUATION:
Hato Piñero, a cattle ranch and world renowned nature preserve and biological station, is situated in the llanos of Venezuela. Since the time the Branger family purchased the land in 1950, cattle ranching operations have worked in harmony with habitat protection. Since the early 1980's, thousands of scientist, educators, students and travelers from all over the world have visited the ranch in order to study and enjoy the natural beauty that is protected there. The nature preserve has been featured in documentaries from PBS's NATURE, National Geographic and CNN to The Discovery Channel. Numerous articles have appeared in the Boston Globe, Los Angeles Times, The New York Times and countless other European publications.

On March 14th, 2005, the National Land Institute, under a land reform campaign that aims to break up large landholdings to distibute among farmers, announced the confiscation of Hato Piñero and all its assets, without compensation, on the grounds that the Branger family failed to provide sufficient proof of ownership and title (read Boston Globe: article). Even though the land was purchased by the Branger family from a private holding in 1950, the institutes' ownership challenge relates to what they consider a "dubious transfer" of title between a Spanish colonial grant and private sale that occurred before 1856. Even though a chain of ownership can be demosntrated as far back as the 1700's, the current Land Law also stipulates that in cases of ownership disputes such as this, ownership is established when the land has been under continuous and uninterrupted use for more than 20 years. More importantly, the law also affords the right to appeal any findings in the courts within sixty (60) days. On March 16th, just days after the official announcement, the director of National Land Institute, Eliezer Otaiza, as judge, jury and enforcer, declared that the confiscation of Hato Piñero and several other ranches would begin immediately, denying the owners any and all due process, despite guarantees specifically articulated in the constitution. Ever since this announcement was made, government representatives have engaged in an orchestrated campaign of smear and distortion attacking the Branger family and the image of Hato Piñero. The aim of these tactics: a total destruction of the highly regarded image of Hato Piñero in order to create something else in its place.

The Branger family is determined to invest all efforts necessary and pursuit all legal avenues available to remedy this situation. We are asking all relevant national and international agencies to aid us by supporting our fight to guarantee the due process and the protection of our constitutional rights. As friends, scientists, educators, fellow travelers, lovers of nature, and citizens of the world, we ask you to remain vigilant to all matters relating to Hato Piñero.

For more information please contact us by e-mail: hatopinero@branger.com, or by phone: Nancy Rincón, (58)212-991.2011.




Caracas April 7, 2005
The Statements Made About Hato Piñero at the National Assembly Yesterday Are Baseless and Reckless

"Hato Piñero is a symbol that cannot be destroyed with the baseless and reckless accusations that pretend to ignore the work we've done for more than five decades in defense of the environment", that is the way that Jaime Perez Branger, president of Agropecuaria San Francisco, the holding entity of Hato Piñero, responded to the accusations made yesterday by the President of INTI, Eliécer Otaiza, before the National Assembly.

"Hato Piñero and its Foundation are neither a front nor a farce. We represent a collective holding of more than 30 families whose hard worked and dedication can be showcased with pride in Venezuela and around the world. One cannot easily ignore the importance of the productive, social and environmental work (the three facets of sustainable development) that has been accomplished at Hato Piñero, as well as its contributions to the alimentary security of the country. At Hato Piñero, and through its Foundation, we've assumed the defense and protection of the environment as our primary purpose."

We Do Protect the Environment
We reject categorically the alleged "environmental or ecological harm" that supposedly has been committed in Hato Piñero", indicated Jaime Perez Branger. "Thanks to our efforts to protect the ecosystems found in the area, species such as the Yellow-Knobbed Curassow, a species in danger of extinction, not only survive but thrive in Hato Piñero; this is a product of the conservation work which we have advanced there. Of equal importance, in the cattle ranch all major feline species existing in Venezuela are represented, demonstrating the fact that they do not represent a limiting factor in the development of cattle ranching activities, considering that these predators have a high diversity of prey such as the capybara, agouti, peccary and deer, to mention a few."

In Hato Piñero there exist 850 floral species which represent 28.33% of the flora of the llanos, covering over 130 botanical families and 494 genus. The herbarium at the ranch has classified more than 2,500 samples of the llanos' flora; especially those in the state of Cojedes, five of those identified there can be considered new species at a worldwide level.

Yes we contribute to the scientific development of the country
Contrary to what the president of INTI said, we can demonstrate that in Hato Piñero the important and thorough research that has been made has helped contribute advanced knowledge of the flora and the fauna of the country. More than 52 scientific studies on subjects such as cattle breeding, agriculture, ecology, and the environment have been carried out by specialists from recognized national and international institutions and universities. Similarly, more than 50 national and international institutions have used the facilities to conduct workshops, teach courses, and participate in internships.

Yes we are productive
Nor can we ignore the productive accomplishments at Hato Piñero. At this moment, in its boundaries graze 11 thousand heads of bovine and buffalo cattle, and 5 thousand kilograms of pasture seeds are harvested. This taking into consideration that the cattle ranch's extension is characterized as follows: 11 thousand hectares pertaining to the massif of El Baul- rock formations not apt for farming; 18 thousand hectares of protected forest which conform the forest known as Chirgua- these are only used for environmental research; 12,500 hectares of the forest of Los Caballos- used for environmental, ecological studies and refuge for species in danger of extinction; and 18 thousand hectares of flooded savannahs that are only used for minimum impact grazing during the summer months. The 15 thousand remaining hectares comprise of natural and planted grasses used in production during winter.

Yes we have an environmental plan
It is necessary to also emphasize that Hato Piñero counts on its own "Plan of Structure and Regulation of Use for Conservation", as an integral environmental management instrument-- unique in the private sector and lacking at the national level-to guide our directives, programs and projects that are being conducted in cattle ranching, ecotourism, environmental education, investigation and conservation.

According to what Perez Branger described, "This Plan voluntarily establishes restrictions of use to areas. It was produced by Annaye Carrizo, a Venezuelan lawyer, while pursuing her Magíster Scientiarum in Environmental Management, of the Experimental University of the Armed Forces. This work obtained the Order of Publication and Honorary Mention.

The cemeteries are not new "discoveries"
According to what was expressed by the President of Agropecuria San Francisco, "Yes, there are 2 cemeteries in Hato Piñero, located in the Northern part, which during the 30's and 40's were used by the people that live near El Baul. But these cemeteries in no way belong to any indigenous ethnic group. In regards to the third cemetery that was referenced, the same one corresponds to a discovery made in 1985 when a group of anthropologists, carrying out studies in the ranch, found these vestiges. An agreement was then established with the Mayor of the town of El Pao and the Institute of Cultural Patrimony of Cojedes State to conduct the necessary scientific research, which was paid mainly by the Agropecuaria San Francisco, holding entity of the ranch. The public authorities, competent in these matters, have all the respective information ".

We do not exploit the land for nonmetallic minerals
Finally, Perez Branger said that in Hato Piñero "we do not operate nonmetallic mining. For reasons beyond our control, during the long period of rains that affected the region between the end of 2004 and the beginning of this year, we were forced to use sand and gravel to repair part of the roads that were seriously damaged so that we could guarantee provisions of food to workers in remote areas and to continue with our daily operations. This activity has been suspended responding to the concerns of the government. In case that corrective action must be taken, we are prepared to execute them immediately ".

For more information please contact:
hatopinero@branger.con and/or lvezga@asesorac.com